畢業生??

[葉仙兒]

咁你地個會到底想代表d乜呢,請問?
唔好side時間去懶醒咁捉字"失"啦...唔該
如果你連人地idn系代表匯集世界不同的國際設計家的作品於一起,都理解錯誤o既話, 我真系勸你講少d自然錯少d吧,獻丑不如藏拙啦,細路~
雖然呀juno個樣系衰d, 不過人地都以事論事咁講gei,你都唔駛懶勁咁去拋英文,話人文盲,講野有point先得架,細路....

[Rascal]

這是一個cg&動畫創作人的討論區.大家有權說出自己的意見.
但請不要因這麼小事大發雷霆&笑別人不懂英文.
大家說你地個會,也只是想說出一點意見吧了.有了批評人才會進步和改進.
如果這樣子也不接受如何代表香港呢
ps[雖然呀juno個樣系衰d, 不過人地都以事論事咁講gei]這句真的很好

[HapZungLam]

What is going on here?

It is not a good idea to turn people down. I mean, it isn't a bad thing to form a associat. Juno tackle their amount of members. Well, this is a new club right? why do you expect there has a lot of members. Also for their quality of work, yea true that they are still in the beginner level. But think about that, they are just grads, not profesional.

What im trying to say is, if we keep turning people down once the new generation has new idea, it is not going to help them. In fact, they'll lose confidence.

[kenken]

有個細路系屋企...佢講d咩野出黎,屋企人唔系鬧佢,串佢,捉佢字虱..,就系叫佢"獻丑不如藏拙...,出少句聲啦~~".........但一方面,呢家人又怪自己屋企d細路唔及隔離屋班靚仔咁醒....................
不過又唔怪得佢家人...,事關佢地細個果陣阿爸阿媽都系咁教佢....

...結果個細路跟住呢套野長大..,日子有功,佢平時都唔多出聲...費事講多錯多...,但有人講錯野就第一個走出黎鬧...;做事亦少錯為妙,最好就系人地做乜自己跟第二...;一方面又驚自己d弟妹叻過自己...,好既唔教,又系教佢"獻丑不如藏拙...,出少句聲啦~~".........

...無論意願如何,將來呢個細路就系會代表呢個屋企.....

[HapZungLam]

can you guys stop that?

[Juno]

我在第一編文章時已說明我的見解:

查實學生哥們集合起來攪下創作也 無可厚非，更藉得鼓勵一下

我沒有打壓畢業學生組織動畫活動，HapZungLam你完全曲解我的意思。

我提出及針對的問題很清楚亦無必要避談，相反只有些人在胡亂的反駁又把話題拉開，別外我由頭到現在也用中文說話，而在取笑我英文不好的人兄，卻說著不合纙輯的英語。

我開這個題目當然預料有反對的意見，但只見那些沖動的反擊，無論點可言。

重申我的立場，我認為一群同校畢業生用 "香港動畫創作協會 "是有問題及沒有代表性的。情況就似一群讀完工聯會舉辨的醫療保健課程後，便成立個"香港醫療保健協會 " ，何解要這樣急進呢?

最後希望你們有論點和立場才好回應 ! 不然就沒討論的意義!!!

[CG-F]

HKAA 會否公開招收會員？
還是只收 HKAC 的同學？
權利與義務又是否一樣？

了解多一點才爭論吧！

[Vector]

Juno, 我支持你,個名好似代表香港咁但又唔多覺可以代表香港

雖然你真系好靚仔

[HapZungLam]

A name is just a representitive. What ever name it is, it doesn't effect what they are doing. A better name, will bring more spirit, more good member.

What kind of name do you suggest, juno?

[Vector]

! sign! I go back to work la see U !!
bye illiterate

sign or sigh?

[Juno]

原本唔想過份針對文章內容的作論點，
不過 HapZungLam 的 三 編文章都充滿矛盾及立場不一，我認為有需要指出來，以正視聽 :


在HapZungLam 的第一編文章說到 :

Also for their quality of work, yea true that they are still in the beginner level. But think about that, they are just grads, not profesional.

HapZungLam也是認為"香港動畫創作協會"這組織 not professional ，無代表性? ~~這點和我的立場竟是一致的


在HapZungLam 的第二編文章說到 :

can you guys stop that?

這句帶有權威性的言論，可惜HapZungLam在不到廿四小時後打破了自己的立場 !

在HapZungLam 的第三編文章說到 :

A name is just a representitive.

這句可謂全文重點 "A name is just a representative "
你想說什麼? 請各位現實一點去談論! 一個有代表性的公會或協會，並不是如此簡單!

HapZungLam 問我 "What kind of name do you suggest, juno?" 我倒沒有意見，但如果我是個剛畢業的學生，我就不會用一些專業的協會名稱，"Ani-nation" 這名也實在不錯 !

[lumay]

HKAA 是公開招收會員.這個會只是成立了不久.雖然這個會的確上未十分成熟.
正所謂萬丈高樓從地起.不論做任何事情都是必須要時間不斷地改善.
大家可必現在就如此快地有這樣大的負面意見呢? juno先生,你不用如此快的睇死別人什麼什麼這樣這樣的不能代表香港.
講真喇!!難得現今還有一班熱血青年,總未為五斗米而雙節腰.為想推動動畫.希望能為 "香港" 動畫界作出一分力.

[CG-F]

公開招收會員也不算是小圈子，努力！

[Tuk]

hi! everyone, agree with CG-F, 如會公開招收會員都唔算系小圈子,既然人地系新會,那就看看以後會點吧!

其實我真系不想這兒變成串人,捉字虱,評人英文水或玩前後不一的地方,算啦!
香港的Animation需要大家的團結.

[HapZungLam]

HapZungLam也是認為"香港動畫創作協會"這組織 not professional ，無代表性? ~~這點和我的立場竟是一致的

Professionalism? it really depend on where do you put it. Do you expect they'll have final fantasy lvl? man, that's not going to happen. Skills will improve, but at this point, it is really what HK can do. Remember, they are all grads. Means that they are reaching the lvl that they can be professional, not to the world, but just in HK.
And probably you mis-understand what i mean. You mean "無代表性" is because their work not good enought to represent HK. And my point is, this is HK lvl in "general".
If you feel that their lvl will make people laugh, then, upgrade, practise more, work harder, study from other country. I always ask myself what lvl am i standing right now. And how can i improve to the level that people will admit. In the other hand, I must upgrade myself to reach my goal. People laugh at me, well, i don't care. just laugh, but please give me suggestions, teach me how to improve. After i feel i have improvements, i'll show my work again for people to critique. This is representing myself.

這句帶有權威性的言論，可惜HapZungLam在不到廿四小時後打破了自己的立場 !

Nonono, this is not what i mean. I ask you guys to stop is that i dont' want you guys to argue on something that only picks on people's word. Be concentrade no our topic, we are discussing, trying to find out a better way of living, not to tackel people's bad language.

這句可謂全文重點 "A name is just a representative "
你想說什麼? 請各位現實一點去談論! 一個有代表性的公會或協會，並不是如此簡單!

I don't really pay that much attention to their name. And a name won't put their lvl into world level. People around the world won't base on their name to judge "this is 代表 HK". So really, a name isn't their consideration. Which means, name, is just a name.

HapZungLam 問我 "What kind of name do you suggest, juno?" 我倒沒有意見，但如果我是個剛畢業的學生，我就不會用一些專業的協會名稱，"Ani-nation" 這名也實在不錯 !

Ani-nation is a good name. but are you don't feel comfortable with their chinese name that has the word "協會"?