[討論] The Lord of the Rings | The Two Towers

[CraZ3D]

好好好勁 !!

雖然我坐到腰骨痛, 但全片也很精彩 , 比上集緊張, Vfx比上集多....
可能我在入場前已先看一次第一集的DVD , 所以看起來便更為投入, 不會覺得悶(某D場景可能比較悶的..)
大量的CG,睇到好高興 ,未段那場'聖盔谷'一戰,更是不可錯過, 好多CG兵但郤很真實.

咕魯的出場次數更是驚人的多( 今集占的戲份更很重), 如此大膽的使用全CG character 做咁多內心戲 , 真系不得不佩服他們. 而且做得很好, 只是有D場景看起來 lighting 唔多夾 . 但我認為只是雞蛋裡挑骨頭!

當然有部 份Visual fx 都唔系話做得好好, 正如先前也有網友話 "樹人"那段某些shot ,Comp得唔太真, 我也有同感...

當我離開戲院時 , 聽到有個男人話 套片'不知所謂'!
真是有趣 , 一套片,唔同的人有唔同感受
我看完這片就很高興的, 更像上了一課!

[Barry Yue]

totally agree!!
And i'd watched the making of "the rings" from ATV tonite, noticed that they are real pro from what they are doing and acting! Meanwhile, the motion of "Kolo" is smooth and nature coz they found a real actor to act it and motion track afterward in the lab. Even though, the lighting is not really match with the background sometimes but this is not really matter anymore, coz they had spend their time and afford at all cost in every places of the movie. This is what i want to say about the movie. Thx

[HapZungLam]

After i watched the 2nd time of the movie. There are even more bad composite is being found by me.

Actually, most of the scene with the 2 hobbits when they'r riding the Ent (big tree) is badly composted.

Compare to the fellowship of the ring, two towers is a hard part to express. Since there has 3 storyline going on. But i think Peter (the director) can do better than that. It gives me some boring and confusing in some parts.

The best part of the whole movie is at the beginning where Gandolf is fighting the lord of the frame (the diablo creature).

[johngalliano]

It's awesome! Peter has really good storying telling talent. Though full of vfx, but never felt it bigger than the story. HK directors like Tsu Hark and Lau Wai Keung should learn it.

To me Gollum is better than perfect!! I think the crowd of Orcs warriors driven by "Massive" really push the technology to an upper level.

But sometimes the camera in battle scenes make me a bit dizzy. I expected great things from this movie and it didn't disappoint me.

[Maya初仔]

[Maya初仔]

[HapZungLam]

Maya初仔 : i dont' think he is.

[Maya初仔]

Maya初仔 : i dont' think he is.

HapZungLam,
He deleted his post, the guy named "Real-Softimage_expert...Maya_User........i'm not talking about johngalliano....Hope johngalliano don't mind!!!

[johngalliano]

hahaha,...of course i won't mind,...though it's not my real name of course....
It's only the name of a great fashion designer...

[Maya初仔]

Tks johngalliano........

[HapZungLam]

oh no, i've missed it. I see you guys haveing a big fight in the other thread. Probably him.

Then that's weird, since i come here quite offen. how can i missed his posts!!!!

[sinnk]

對於TWO TOWERS系STORY方面因為要忠於書及片長關系, 的確交代得吾系太好, 冇睇書或第一集的人可能吾知佢講D咩, 但整體都算系中上之作。
就畫面構圖方面, 我覺得系樹精同GANDOLF開頭出場時做得吾系太好, 可能系想俾人有D神既感覺, 所以吾系太真, 另外咕嚕真的做得很好, 能做到咁生動及咁多表情已經好難, 仲要系咁大特寫, 好明顯對於呢個CG連導演都覺得正(佢D大頭仲多過D演員)

[含羞草]

強強強強強強強強強強強強強強強