[討論] Spider-Man 2《 蜘 蛛 俠 2 》

[ZU]

[討論] Spider-Man 2《 蜘 蛛 俠 2 》 :

[ 請在此區發表 < 蜘 蛛 俠 2 > 觀後討論 ]

[CraZ3D]

勁 !!!
嘩 ~~ 好正呀,
雖然飛天鏡頭唔系好多 , 亦有些鏡頭之前看過 , 但在大銀幕看真的很勁 , 好high ~~
( http://www.cgvs.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=489 )
以上系小弟兩年前系度為蜘蛛俠1 post 過的內容.... 咁就兩年 ....

今晚睇完套片之後幾小時 , d 鏡頭仲留系腦海裡, 有幾場d 打斗快到睇唔清楚 , 只見 CG stunt 搖來搖去 , 個女角依然咁丑樣
最後一幕又系精彩的飛天鏡頭 , .. 不過仲乜要整多兩架 helicopter出黎...有點多舊魚...

[h2o]

直升機應該系好後期先加上去, 因為d 質感同燈光都未做得好好..... 真系好假

cg stunt 打斗既場面好多時都 blur 勁左, 感覺怪怪的

今只 spiderman 件衫d 紅色鮮左又"令"左, 做 cg 時都幾難夾, 成日都覺得跳左出黎

[hollowman]

yes, h2o, i agree with u, the CGI r so fake,
y sony image work can produce such CGI? the motion blur not correct, the color not match...etc.

i think spiderman 3 CG should come hk to make
and let h2o be the superviser, then will not make those fake CG again. right?

h2o, whick company u r working in? i heard about that u r a director or something .... right?

[cgworker]

就算唔識 CGI 都睇得出 邊d場面系做得 fake ! 除非你系果d以為find nemo 系用真魚拍的傻仔.
如果每個寫對電影觀後感o既人都要有資格, 咁呢個世界就無"影評"
人地睇到做得唔靚 , 你就叫人不如去拍 !
.. 咁呢個世界就只有George Lucas , Andy Wachowski, Bryan Singer,David Fincher 呢 d 導演先有資格話睇倒 d fake CGI !

hollowman你無野下話 !!!

[hollowman]

oh. whats wrong?
i m just a beginner of cg and i really agree with h2o
i don't know what is the stardard of hong kong cg company can do
i think h2o can see those detail that the animator of spiderman 2 can't see, so isn't he or his company can do the spiderman 3??
i don't know whats wrong ? cgworker?
i haven't ask him to "make" the movie, he is not a director of movie
i ask him to supervise the cg, do u understand? isn't that impossible? u tell me please cgworker. u just misunderstand my message and say other things....

[Dr Maya]

hollowman: "i think spiderman 3 CG should come hk to make
and let h2o be the superviser, then will not make those fake CG again. right?"



笑死人~!
成日都有d咁慨人~!

[hollowman]

what so funny?

[EricLo]

vfx的確系比較有少許品質下降，但在數量和復雜度上真的有提升了很多，
我最欣賞在鐵路對戰這場，好有迫力呀!!
Overall 比Spirdman 1 更好睇

ericlo - 2004

[Bankrupt]

Wah~d cg sipderman 好難做呵,
不如你試下做oh~hollowman~我諗你得o既~haha

[shady_lady]

未睇不過香港人如果拿倒2億加多一千萬去做，應該差唔得太多.....

少說無建設的挑釁語言，不要學維園阿伯，楂住柺杖，四圍亂篤，勾人衫尾......九月十二再泥多鋪。

[Dr Maya]

[~高燈星拖~]

我是MAYA的初哥呢~! 真的不懂分辨何處是真, 何處是假~~! .... 請問咁多位都系HK CG界的老大哥嗎?

[CraZ3D]

其實唔只 spider-man , even Doc Ock 個 stunt 有幾場睇落都假左d.

回看Matrix 2 /3 , Hulk, 及其他各套FX大片都一定會有呢個情況.
要做到好真.還得要很多時間呢! 不過如果可以再真的點, 我就更會贊歎多點呢!

今集鏡頭依然玩得好型,由其打斗時, 好難想像.

[Dr Maya]

好好睇~
蜘蛛俠內心戲拍得好, 好有feel, 特技系有幾個shot會假d, 但己經好勁, 入得場都會當佢漫畫片咁睇, 假得合理~~~
最正系蜘蛛俠想盡辦法出盡力整停火車個段, 好勁同之後市民好齊心, 好touching.....

最尾收場有幾架直升機在飛, 個d系police直升機, 因為有事故發生嘛, 可能咁樣散場型d呢, 系"漫畫"英雄片呀~