VTC maya course

[feverheat]

http://detech.vtc.edu.hk/html/c1108.htm
我有個中五朋友暑假報左呢個course唔知大家覺得初學者有冇用呢！？

[古董動畫人]

如果你想讀好maya 或者animation ，我提議你去CityU 好過去搵呢位黃生啦...小心小心，除非你想讀完淨系識motioncap啦...

[feverheat]

我都明白既，因為佢話佢報左，唔知得唔得，所以post上黎，等大家俾D意見佢囉！！ 講明啊！唔系我啊

[pirotase]

黃X達Terence Wong !!!
Haha !!!
If he is teaching the course , I think you dont need to worry ... ... he do have skills on maya =)
and City U too much ppl apply and expensive ~~
hehe ...
and Mocap ..hmm .......I think you will learn Maya more than mocap in this course ....
Trust me .......
But if your friend lazy and only reliab on other ppl ...he wont get anythings....


Hope Mr Wong dont see this msg hahaha.....

Pirotase

p.s 古董動畫人 hmm u know Mr 黃X達 ?? haha ...

[古董動畫人]

我跟這位黃先生有過幾面之緣，若然你可以看過他以前的作品，而你又到過他的學生作回展，你便可以知道由他教出來的學生水准會到達哪一個水平啦。

[h2o]

... IVE (Kwung Tong) 學生作品我都有看過,若只看他們的CG,我想這未免太不公平吧.因為他們讀的是multimedia,Maya只占一部份,俱俱兩三年也不能期望太高.如果3d animation是這麼易的話,我們很難搵飯食喇!
我亦相信系香港很難有學校願意開辦兩到三年純animation課程;
第一,未有足夠經驗
第二,投放資源也需要很多,學費不能太貴,收生也不能太多
第三,就業問題... (大家心照啦!)
初哥們一定要學的話,最好讀短期course打好根基(set project 也不懂,邊有公司會請你!),跟住再睇書靠自己進修,做靚個porfo,這行工作者都沒有受填鴨式教育出來的.

[feverheat]

多謝你地既意見，我想問下有冇D書可以介紹下啊？

[古董動畫人]

這問你提出那幾點跟黃老師懂不懂得教書有甚家直接關系 ? 我看就只有第一點吧了，就是未有足夠經驗...教吧...

太高期望 ? 咁我地可以set 低 d o既，個學生識set keyframe 就叫識做 animation 夠低未 ? 未 ? 咁不如佢識click maya 個icon 就叫識夠低未 ? 咁請問閣o既標准又系咩呢，請問 ?

仲有如果 set project 系學動畫o既基本，咁香港o既動畫就玩完啦....

[heha]

Don't worry, He do have little skills on maya, cause my friend told me that he already finish the course in City U, Although he is not the best in his class. But that IVE course is so cheap, you can't except anything.

[古董動畫人]

都o巖

[h2o]

黃老師懂不懂得教書?這應該由他的學生來評比較合理.你看來是他的學生唷... ...

我o既標准?我只希望他們別強逼自己周身刀...找到自己的興趣後,再專注學好它.Graphic, CG animation, CG Lighting & Tex, Effects, Editing... ... choose one or two, 因為時間實在不多.

Maya set project 系第一堂教麻.

書個方面呢,我會睇 interior design 做 lighting reference.
motion 呢, 我最愛睇馬戲表演, 其次系同運動有關.
facial 就睇戲同埋自己塊面啦
tech & cheats 就睇 cinefex, making-of & 自己試多D,嘗試自己解決問題

我仲有個唔知好定壞既習慣,就系打書釘.呢間睇一個鍾,第二間又睇一個鍾,咁就差唔多睇哂本書,又慳錢.

[pirotase]

古董動畫人 是黃Ｘ達的學生嗎？ 如果不是，我想你一定與他有仇 (:P)
哈~
而且如果沒有親身經歷，根本無法定斷好壞 , Right?
你所看過的是那年學生的作品呢？今年？

Pirotase

[古董動畫人]

哈哈，果然有回響喎，你唔洗咁努氣喎。


我唔系佢學生，亦唔系同佢有仇，只系熟知呢位大佬o既工作模式嗜，anyway，我一直無評價佢o既學生質素，我只系問緊如果你睇過今年佢 d 學生作品，你就會知道佢地系哪一個水平罷了，你並無指明是高是低，只是你提及唔能夠期望太高嗜，咁認為佢地無好o既質素o既，似乎系閣下，唔系我，黃老師教左書無耐，相對於 cityu o既老師，唔夠經驗系一個事實，毋用至疑，但教得好唔好呢 ? 我亦無評價喎，我有講佢教得唔好咩 ? 佢似乎比較睇重 mocap ，所以我認為佢會花多d 時間響教mocap o既野，咁有機會其他項目失去平衡，但系cityU 方面似乎做得比較好 d ，所以我咁suggest 嗜，有咩問題先 ?

[古董動畫人]

你又咁維護佢，唔通你同佢有親 ?

哈哈哈，講笑講笑。

我睇過佢學生今年o既作品，我又想問下，你點睇佢 d 學生o既作品呢 ?

[heha]

Anyway, it is hard to compare with the teachers in CityU, a lot of people outside that they are teaching Maya are usually CityU student. Like Art Centre, they are also using CityU student to teaching their Maya course. I think it depends on the teacher that they have or haven't prepare for the class.