Maya 8.5 SP1 Split Poly Tool Fail?

[bbkill]

有冇 user 用Maya 8.5 SP1 Split Polygon Tool 有不正常情況?

我用個Split 10次有6次都split 唔到。 edge to edge split (中間冇加split point) 就通常都可以，但如果要split 好似破璃裂紋咁就好多時都唔work (有history 但冇split 到)。

search 過web都見過有咁o既問題~~

[CraZ3D]

系咪咁樣 ?
我個maya 8.5 SP1好似無事喎.....

[bbkill]

系咪咁樣 ?
我個maya 8.5 SP1好似無事喎.....

yes, you are doing edge to edge straight splitting with no extra split point on a split line.

here is the situation:

[stantang]

Try to bring up the "Snapping tolerance". Sometimes you can't close the split completely if it's too low (respect to your scene scale), which causes the split action fail.

[CraZ3D]

ic ...ic..

呢個 case 我諗唔系Snapping tolerance 既問題..應該系..BUG

我試過用 7 同 8 都無事...
有人問呢個問題 , 不過無人有答案

等MAYA 2008...再試下

[stantang]

Do you get any warning? The most common one is "Warning: The last selection did not end on an edge, proceeding with partial split."

[bbkill]

bad luck, I still got most of the split failed even if I tuned the tolerance value.

Official report from Autodesk on 8.5 SP1 says the fail is related to the object scaling and it can be solved by freeze transform. Well, not working at all.

[stantang]

...Official report from Autodesk on 8.5 SP1 says the fail is related to the object scaling and it can be solved by freeze transform. Well, not working at all.

The bug was in 8.5 and the offical doc said it has been fixed in sp1...

May be the fix creates another bug as many other things in Maya...

[h2o]

沒完沒了