露寶芝

[Wolf]

去捧我friend場。各方面技術真系一流 (除咗前面火車站裡面嘅蒸氣)，不過就電影嚟講，個劇情同鏡頭運用真系老土同熟口熟面到不堪。依家啲動畫片唔知搞乜鬼，系咁用visual同gag粉飾極之空洞嘅內容。再咁落去，玩唔耐 (睇迪斯尼2D嘅下場就知)。就怕到香港業界有咗咁上下技術斤兩嘅時候，3D動畫已經俾美國佬玩"謝"曬。

[stantang]

Personally, I think the american style 3d animation "has been" overdone already. The Franch are coming up strong with refreshing storytelling and a bit twisted (not for kid/teenage) mindset which is turly amazing.

[HammerChugoh]

This is just a beginning, Chicken little and Valiant will be even worse. So it's time to say good bye to the golden age of 3D animation.

[Wolf]

French? If you mean "Kaena" then I'm afraid I'll have to pass it on.

But yeah, the face attraction of 3D animation is beginning to wear off -- I first caught this, believe it or not, in "Incredibles." That film, despite all the rave reviews it got, looks tired. Both PRMan and the storytelling formula were obviously pushed to seam-bursting limits. It's sad actually, because it's beginning to seem that Asian 3D animation studios might just be catching (if at all) the last fad wagon to limbo.

[bbkill]

Personally, I think the american style 3d animation "has been" overdone already. The Franch are coming up strong with refreshing storytelling and a bit twisted (not for kid/teenage) mindset which is turly amazing.

agree with the French idea~~~France is incrediblely good at storytelling and they have lots of unique and special style in art~~~I love french comic books~~~

[stantang]

Wolf, I'm not talking about Kaena as I haven't seen it yet. I mean in terms of shorts not features, the French are kicking.

[CraZ3D]

哇~wolf 兄連 "Incredibles." 都睇到悶 , 果然高幾班~
你又點睇套 "Cars"先,
我仍然覺得PIXAR 系最後希望 ,.. CARS 之後系乜呢, 好神秘咁喎..

相反睇見Dreamworks黎緊狂出d動畫片. Dinsey自己立埋 ToyStory3 ,
真系令人膽心..

[kingnt66]

I mean in terms of shorts not features, the French are kicking.

This is very subjective, from my perspective, French production(especailly short film) are usually gloomy, dark, and twisted. Their ideas are creative and fresh, but Creative + Fresh not always equal to "Good". But surely that we can learn a lot from the French.

PS. I think most of the film from Pixar are excellent, especailly Toy Story 2 and Incredibles. I don't think people will get tired of PRman, we will only tired of cheesy storyline like the Cinderalla sequel by Disney

[luxoJr]

CARS 之後系乜呢, 好神秘咁喎..

Ratatouille (scheduled for release in 2007)

[Wolf]

法國動畫短片，我完全未睇過。可以介紹幾套俾我嗎？近期我只睇過一套《瘋狂約會美麗都》，系非常非常之好嘅作品，露寶治荒失奇兵呢啲同佢比，優劣立見。

>你又點睇套 "Cars"先

等佢上咗畫，我再同你講。

[stantang]

介紹幾套呀?我一時都諗吾到，不過近年electronic threater都有吾少法國作品。

[pazu]

睇全3d都睇到好厭, 近來就得Incredibles掂.對上已經唔知系邊套.
加上套套d造型都系懶q懶可愛
史力加就 但仲有續集, 好似港產片,得就o系咁續集. 但系d橋就唔系好得.
對car d造型冇咩好感

[luxoJr]

初初睇incredibles既造型都唔多好感, 不過睇到片的時候就唔同曬, 佢地勁在可以做到有靈魂既character!

[moc]

點解唔試著去....睇它值得的一面....
我自己覺得.....露寶至......可以跟incredibles作同級喎...
個人頗喜歡它........喜歡它們的造型....它們的設定.....
很多位置其實在見到用心機的諗過度過....造型更加不在話下....
倒十分覺得....現在的全動畫片....因為它們主打客戶是小朋友.....
所以劇情非常非常淺白.....利用角色的大量動作來交代......露寶至更加凸顯了這一點......劇情十分明快......快...呀.....所以像角子老虎機般......什麼都以流竄形式.......快呀..........或者roller....溜冰呀.......這個是年長的咱們找不到想要的依托.....因為一般年長的....較想了解劇情....對動作沒興趣...因為看太多了....倒是角色的刻劃....想 更深入.........
講動作細膩及韻律感...我則喜歡"荒失失奇兵"..嘩.....動物們的大量跳舞動作.......大家要留意咯......那種特有的"韻律感"很強.....強過咱們看過的其他......恐怕調動作的動畫師們全都經己成了經常手舞足蹈.....的舞林高手...
不過個人不喜歡它當中那份大美國.....英雄救贖主義.......無端端跑去擾亂人家國土的生態平衡........然後懶系帶住單方面榮耀回歸......完全系現在美國佬的寫照.....short....
另一套真的很屎的..是那個"沙魚大話王".....可以說....它是同類片種的最低潮位......希望唔好再有.....它的劇情........角色造型.....動作......鋪排.....笑位.....無謂提........完全系失敗作......

[stantang]

Agree with what moc said. Love the animation of 荒失失奇兵 but hated its story. As for Shark Tale, it's so bad that actually made me give up on watching 3d animated features for a while....