[討論] 聖誕新年假上畫電影, 你看了那套?

[Willow]

Agree with leeho,無間道is not very good, is basic requirment (for audience to pay for ticket). For my habit such HK make Movies I will only rent VCD only (Although I pay to see with my firends in such big holiday)

On the other hand, HK movies always talk about 警察,古惑仔,雞? Can they make other kind of story?

[HapZungLam]

On the other hand, HK movies always talk about 警察,古惑仔,雞? Can they make other kind of story?

I guess base on the buget, they won't able to get any further.

[feverheat]

Hi, I watched the Two towers also yesterday in exhibition center.

This time, a little bit disappointed, seems the story too long unnecessarily. WHAT DO YOU THINK?

But I like the CG character, it seems like the one in Harry potter, but he is more relistic and jsut like an actor. What do you think , harry potter's or Two tower's ? I tried to find any 破碇 , but .... so perfect ...

[CraZ3D]

遲來講 "英雄"

張藝謀拍的國際性的商業片 "英雄" , 其實已拍到商業片的水准 , 再加上拍得很華麗的場面 ,可謂集商業與藝術一起. 當然和張導演以前的"寫實藝術片"比較是不一樣的.

內容方面, 張導演這次說的"英雄", 其實有點誤導. "手中無劍 . 心中無劍 " 用一個像很有遠見的殘劍去 預言"秦"統一天下 . 最後不論有遠見或無遠見的人都死了.. 誰是英雄 ? 我想片名叫"刺客烈傳"比較貼切.

雖然這片有某些地方給人歌頌秦一統天下的意識 , 但我卻不認同把它太政治化,
其實拍有關秦國故事的電影已經不是第一 二次(如 陳凱歌拍過的"荊軻刺秦王") ,
張藝謀要再拍的話 , 或多或小都應該有些突破或有所不同 . 可以看到故事結構是有心思安排的 . 但到底要拍刺秦的話 ,結局也離不開 秦王不死 , 刺秦者死 . 然而張藝謀選擇了一個較具爭議的方向吧!


feverheat 兄 ,
對於LOTR -TwoTowers 是否期望太高 ? 所以無咁好睇 ?
我尚未看 但卻很期望 .....

[HapZungLam]

there has 2 IK snap on the knee of the trees. didn't you see that? also when the 2 hobbits were riding on the tree at night. That scene is badly composite.

[feverheat]

there has 2 IK snap on the knee of the trees. didn't you see that? also when the 2 hobbits were riding on the tree at night. That scene is badly composite.

that's right, seems composit by two different team. The light is not natural. But I didn't see the IK snap.

[feverheat]

遲來講 "英雄"


feverheat 兄 ,
對於LOTR -TwoTowers 是否期望太高 ? 所以無咁好睇 ?
我尚未看 但卻很期望 .....

maybe they need to base on the novel, and story not reach the 高潮..

[BMBM]

我認為"英雄"是張導演成名後最具野心而又最無把握的作品，野心是那制作班底(當然連投資者)的共同願望，無把握是整個制作團隊大部份都是導演不太熟識的。他甚至沒有辦法把一個美麗的中文字表現給觀眾看(那個"劍"字只有給我覺得羞家)，個人覺得張導演的文學修養未可應付這次制作，投資者及相關的創作人員都好大喜功，虛假造作。對於中國文化的美化及推廣，功效應該不及"虎臧龍"。
作品品質當然是上等的，但我就是看得不自在。
不過在支持國人電影的前題下，當然是支持的，但下次請不要在大庭廣眾下支持暴君好嗎？你總不能想像在西方國度的電影工作者會將希特勒說成是統一歐洲的英雄嘛！

[BMBM]

看"英雄"唯一開心的是欣賞甄子丹的勁身手，我覺得他的身手直逼李小龍！